Bettering Butternuts

Final update: Winter 2023

A 2022 Bettering Butternut project is for UMN Extension natural resources volunteer, landowners and professionals that identify native butternut trees, assesses butternut canker impact and reports mostly healthy butternuts to iNaturalist to inform and support butternut recovery efforts in Minnesota. 

Final Report: 2022 Bettering Butternuts

Thank you!

In total 56 new butternut observations, 45 of which were verified to research grade, were reported to iNaturalist from July 1 through December 31, 2022. This represents a 67% increase in research grade iNaturalist reports of butternuts in Minnesota during the project period. 

Project Overview

A 2022 Bettering Butternut project is for UMN Extension natural resources volunteer, landowners and professionals that identify native butternut trees, assesses butternut canker impact and reports mostly healthy butternuts to iNaturalist to inform and support butternut recovery efforts in Minnesota. 

How you can help

Report mostly healthy (see below for details) butternut trees to iNaturalist. Be sure to mark them as "Butternut Juglans cinerea" unless you think they are hybrids. If you think they may be hybrids mark them as "Bixby's Walnut Juglans × bixbyi". We really only want butternut, but understand the hybrids and native butternuts can be very hard to distinguish. Our experts will confirm identification in iNaturalist or follow-up with the reporter if needed.

We'll need as many good pictures as you can upload to iNaturalist, likely 4, see specific directions for what type of pictures in the "Assessing and recording butternut health" section below. In addition we need accurate location information and the date, both basic features of iNat reports. If the tree is a yard or community tree be sure to toggle over the cultivate choice at the bottom of the iNat report.

Butternut identification

Butternut identification is complicated because it hybridizes easily with Japanese walnut (Juglans ailanthifolia) and heartnut, a Japanese walnut cultivar, which are both sold in trade and are highly resistant to butternut canker.

Purdue University has a great online resource: Identification of Butternuts and Butternut Hybrids to help sort out identification.  

Photo: Paul Wray, Iowa State University, Bugwood.org

Assessing and recording butternut health

We're using the 70-20-50 rule to assess health:  70% live canopy crown and 20% or less of the flare impacted by butter canker (combined circumference of the bole and root flare affected by butternut canker) OR least 50% live crown and no cankers on the bole or root flares. 

Butternut identification

Confirm it's native butternut

We need one good pictures to confirm it's native butternut. This could be nuts (you'll need to beat the wildlife to them) leaf scare preferable.


Photo: Bill Cook, Michigan State University, Bugwood.org

Butternut root flare

20% or less of the combined circumference of root flare affected by butternut canker

We need two pictures of the root flare, one picture on each side of the tree to assess the percent of canker at the tree base. The canker spreads downward because of gravity so inspecting the base of the tree is a good general indicator of health.

Photo: A. Gupta, UMN Extension

Butternut canopy crown

70% live crown & 20% or less canker at root flare 

OR 

50% live canopy crown and no canker 

We need one good pictures of the top of the tree to assess canopy crown health. Several 

Photo: Robert L. Anderson, USDA Forest Service, Bugwood.org

Butternut restrictions in MN

Butternut is listed by the MN Department of Natural Resources (DNR) as an endangered species. As such a permit is needed to manipulate live health trees. For this project we are only asking participants to take pictures and record the date and location (basic information in iNaturalist). If you want to do anything more with your healthy butternuts you must fall the MN DNR's policies

All questions about this project should be directed to Angela Gupta, UMN Extension Forester, agupta@umn.edu